Gold Investing: Why It’s Just a Game of Musical Chairs

Sep 17

Share this article:

It just hit new all-time highs of $3,500 per ounce. Analysts are calling for $6,900. Some are saying it’s “the hottest investment on the planet.”

At first glance, that sounds tempting. Who wouldn’t want to double their money just by holding a shiny piece of metal?

But here’s the problem: gold isn’t an income-producing asset. It doesn’t pay dividends. It doesn’t generate cash flow. It just sits there.

And that makes investing in gold a lot like playing musical chairs.

The Musical Chairs Analogy

Remember playing musical chairs as a kid? Everyone circles around happily while the music plays. But the moment the music stops, panic sets in because someone will be left without a seat.

That’s exactly how gold works.

While prices are climbing, everyone feels safe. But when sentiment changes and the “music stops,” prices can crash just as quickly as they rose.

Those left standing are the ones who bought in at the top, hoping to sell to someone else at an even higher price.

That isn’t investing. That’s speculation.

When the Music Stopped for Gold

History shows us that gold can tumble just as fast as it rises:

  • 1980 Crash: Gold hit around $850/oz in January 1980 during a period of double-digit inflation and geopolitical shocks. But by 1982, it had fallen below $350, wiping out around 60–70% of value for investors who bought at the peak.
  • ,2011–2015 Decline: Gold climbed to nearly $1,900/oz in 2011 during the European debt crisis. But by late 2015, it had plunged to $1,050, a 45% drawdown that left late buyers stranded.
  • 2020–2022 Pullback: Gold surged above $2,000/oz in 2020 during the pandemic panic. But as economies stabilized and interest rates rose, it fell back below $1,700 in parts of 2022—a painful reminder that “safe havens” don’t always protect everyone.

Each time, those who treated gold like an investment ended up playing musical chairs. And many were left standing.

Why Gold Fails the Value Investing Test

True Value Investing is about buying businesses that create real value over time:

  • Companies with growing earnings
  • Strong cash flows that can be reinvested or paid as dividends 
  • Durable competitive advantages
  • A clear intrinsic value that can be measured
Gold has none of these qualities. It doesn’t innovate. It doesn’t expand. It doesn’t compound wealth.

Warren Buffett has long avoided gold for this exact reason, because unlike great businesses, gold doesn’t “do” anything.

What Smart Investors Do Instead

Instead of chasing the next hot trend, smart investors focus on businesses with long-term growth potential.

  • Coca-Cola sells billions of drinks every year, each one adds to shareholder value
  • Apple continues to innovate and expand its ecosytstem
  • A company with increasing free cash flow can reward shareholders through dividends and compounding growth
Over time, this creates sustainable wealth. Something gold can never deliver.

The Key Takeaway

The hype around gold is exciting—until the music stops.

If you’re serious about building wealth, don’t get caught standing when the music ends. Focus on assets that produce income and grow value over time.

That’s the timeless power of Value Investing.

👉 Want to see how to apply this approach to real-world companies? Scroll down to register for our upcoming webinar.

Share this article

How to Apply a Fundamental-First Approach to Investing

In the midst of global trade tensions and market uncertainties, discover how smart investors are adapting and thriving using ViA Atlas.

Presented by Cayden Chang

Founder of Value Investing Academy and Award-Winning International Speaker, Lifelong Learner Award 2008, Personal Brand Award 2017, 2025 Spirit of Enterprise Honouree

You will learn:

  • How to navigate market uncertainty amidst geopolitical tensions and market uncertainty
  • How can all-weather portfolio of stocks, bonds, and ETFs can help you stay calm and thrive no matter the market direction.
  • How Cash-Flow Options Strategies (CFOS), modelled after Warren Buffett's principles of Value Investing can help you cope with market uncertainty
  • How ViA Atlas could help you strengthen your portfolio and streamline your decision-making process
  • Actionable & Duplicable Step-By-Step Value Investing Framework on identifying high-quality resilent companies


Click the button below to reserve your spot now.